Pinpoint Education

The leading-edge continuing education resource for massage professionals, manual therapists, and bodyworkers.

  • Facebook
  • Google+
  • LinkedIn
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • Home
  • Classes
  • FORUMS
    • Join Our FaceBook Group
    • Pain Science Social Hour!
    • Pinpoint Community Forums (in progress)
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • Log In
    • Pinpoint Members
    • PCOM Students
  • Member Library
  • Pain Science Social Hour!
  • OPEN Bodywork
  • Free Public Resources
You are here: Home / Archives for advancement

Modalites vs. Concepts in Massage Therapy

March 6, 2017 by Tania 14 Comments

[Written while listening to this]

Massage therapy has become a battle ground for modalities. Some claim to be new and others are considered more traditional. There are clever hybrids and tribrids of the different schools in between. The truth is, touch and manual therapy have been around since the evolution of hands and there’s not much new under the sun regarding what we do with them. It’s all been done and touch will continue to be applied under all kinds of labels. It’s fun to get creative with our hands as therapeutic tools and call it marketable stuff. Please let me know in the comment section if you’ve encountered the modality church phenomenon described below!

What makes a massage a modality?

I like to think of massage therapy as music (perhaps because I’m a musician, but painting, sculpting, engineering, and other analogies work just as well). As we know, music is comprised of basic beats/rhythms, notes/tonalities, and spaces in between called rests. Certain combinations of beats and notes get categorized as different genres, or in our case, modalities. There is classical music, world music, metal, punk, free jazz, music-sheet-1275485_640bebop, etc. Bodywork modalities are just as nuanced and varied.

We use methods from the East and West, both mysterious and medical. Ancient and modern. Experimental and clinical. There are almost as many theories as there are modalities, but touch is touch. Music is music. What matters is an understanding of the researched fundamentals to make it functional. Everything else is personal preference, still under investigation, or completely made-up.

Certification, shmertification

Diversity in practice is a wonderful characteristic of our profession. No one modality is better or worse than another. They can all be effective. They can all fall short. Positive outcomes are based on the following:

  • establishing a trustworthy therapeutic relationship
  • client beliefs and expectations
  • understanding the principles of physiology and touch
  • understanding the best applications of your particular “toolkit” (the how-and-when-to-use-or-not-use your choice of techniques)
  • perhaps, a little luck

certificate-31872_1280These understandings can be intuitive or cerebral, however, a good clinical outcome has nothing to do with a certification in one thing vs. zero certifications in anything. Certifications are a nice touch to hang on the wall and indeed note an accomplishment, but they are not to be credited as a justification for results. Not in this line of work. For what it’s worth, I’ve gotten fantastic results from many uncertified novices who have no ego about it. And I’ve come out unaffected and sometimes worse at the hands of professionals who flash credentials like a badge of authority. Certifications are not exclusive qualifiers nor can they guarantee results.

Anatomy of a Modality

human-skeleton-1158318_640In every modality fundamental concepts are at play the moment we put our hands on somebody. It doesn’t matter if I’m performing Shiatsu or Swedish. Nerves light up when they are pressed or stroked, with or without lubricant. The sensations and combinations of tactile stimuli may translate differently in the brain, but pressure is pressure, stretch is stretch, warmth is warmth, traction is traction, and vibration is vibration.

There are also reflexes in the body we can learn to use to our advantage as we develop our sensitivity; like reciprocal inhibition, the crossed-extensor reflex, myotatic and tendon reflexes. Lastly, we can wrap all of the above in layers of neuroscience, psychology, and consciousness to make for a very rich palette of techniques with theoretical complexities. You can throw in toys like foam rollers, cupping, and IASTM (not an endorsement for any, just examples), still, the basic concepts are what hold up.

Different instructors will select certain basic bodywork elements and combine them in ways they have found to be effective. But guess what? All touch can be effective when applied appropriately and with genuine care. In all hands-on CE classes, you’re basically learning a different take on touch. This is a fantastic way to freshen our practice and pick up other ideas. It is invaluable to discover alternate ways of approaching the body. Learning cool moves, old and new, keeps us fresh, curious, and excited about our work.

Plot twist

vader-2023850_640What happens when an instructor patents their preferred approach under the guise of “proprietary information”? I chuckle, lol. You can’t exactly patent or trademark touch, silly goose. However, this flavor of instructor-with-guru-complex often succeeds in creating what Paul Ingraham calls a modality empire. (Thanks for calling it what it actually is, Paul!) It is merely clever marketing of recycled manual interventions. The ™ symbol is added to aid in amassing a church of followers who will spread the gospel for their guru (as if their certification will spare them from ever having to exercise critical thinking in practice).

I am going to call this type of institution a modality church instead, because the dogmas often borderline on religious fanaticism. The majority of these dogmas have been systematically disproven or remain completely unproven. I’m not sure which is worse, but I’ll bet you $50 a modality church guru will throw a belligerent tantrum if you challenge claims. Then they will invariably try to shame you for questioning them. Go on, try it!

The modality church

churchWhat does it take to create a modality church?

  • Rename the basic reflexes using your own invented terminology. Make it sound “revolutionary”.
  • Create your own cliquey modality language.
  • Insert sciencey-sounding word confetti that doesn’t really mean anything and can’t be specifically referenced.
  • Present your modality as if it were beyond the science and/or keep your methods very secret. The secrets will only be revealed after your students have taken all the modules of your modality. Be sure they never actually understand the explanations of  how you say it works. Make them believe this is because they will never fully grasp the enormity of your therapeutic holy grail.
  • Use buzzwords to create an impression you’re the modality master. Print many branded materials further affirming you as master.

Adam Meakins of The Sports Physiotherapist whipped up this hilarious and handy grid. You can use it to create your own modality lol (seriously don’t, we’re all set with “new” modalities):

Of course it’s perfectly fine to do this and I’ve taken a couple of classes that sound like they were pulled from the above grid. I even enjoyed them and learned lots of useful tidbits. Labels help us categorize approaches. However, realize trademarks significantly help in charging heaps more for a course and creating a cult following! Remember: you can trademark a name (that’s fine) but you cannot trademark any sort of touch. If so, sue me!

The modality church guru

I like to make up names for my therapeutic hand jives, too. The difference is I wouldn’t call a manual application my unique invention nor claim the rights to how you, as a student, should reference it. But many will try to do exactly that. When the creator of a modality church assumes the grandiose personality of an infallible know-it-all-touch-inventor (instead of someone you invest in to share useful chunks of actionable information with clarity), you have yourself a modality church guru.

Hand jiving via GIPHY

Unfortunately, there is no shortage of useless information and word confetti. For example, consider obvious nonsense like astrology massage that is being peddled as valid continuing education for our healthcare profession (barf, don’t get me started). It’s fine as a hobby, but a laughable idea in a professional practice. I can’t list examples of a specific modality church because several “gurus” have literally resorted to bullying and suing people who debunk their claims or leak their “secrets”. I ain’t got time for dat.

Buyer beware

I write this in the hopes MT professionals become more selective about the classes and concepts they invest in. That’s right: CONCEPTS. I wasn’t alwaysScreen Shot 2017-03-21 at 9.38.59 PM so skeptically discerning and have flushed plenty of money down the toilet on bogus classes. So, before plunking down your hard earned dollars on a CE course, I encourage you to dig into the underlying concepts the instructor offers in relation to that modality. Manual therapy techniques are not new anymore. So how are they presenting the concepts of their application? As theory or fact? As gospel or as an interesting perspective? Is it plausible? Ask for the research, then go a step further and research their research.

This-is-how-I-like-to-do-it-ies

It would thrill me if somehow the term modalities could be changed to this-is-how-I-like-to-do-it-ies, because that is basically what they are. It is much more accurate. They’re just how a particular instructor offers approaches, and those approaches should be based on solid science (we would think). My OPEN Bodywork class is basically about how I like to work it and why, based on sound science and years of reasoning.

gearsModalities are not to be confused with specializations, like oncology massage or chronic pain relief. Nor should they be confused with traditional systemized approaches like Nuad Bo Rarn/Thai massage or Shiatsu, whose foundations are based in spiritual and religious philosophies (ex., Thai massage has its roots in Buddhism and Shiatsu is based on the Chinese system of acupressure which is founded on Confucianism, but neither are based on physiology). Having an appreciation of the philosophy of a traditional approach is wonderful and beautiful, but philosophies are not the fundamentals. They are merely intangible beliefs that cannot be substituted for a very tangible understanding of physiology. Beliefs vary widely and often on any given day. Human physiology does not. It’s the only constant we can trust in our work. The rest is just personal adornment.

Conclusion

Modalities are not to be confused with the underlying concepts of how their applications may work. It is important to understand the difference. For example, I can petrissage a trapezius and offer 2 explanations:

  1. I am squeezing energy out of the meridians found in that muscle and also stretching the fascia that reaches into their lower back. This works by combining an ancient philosophy with a modern theory. You have to learn it the way I tell you. I’m actually the only one who’s ever figured out how to move my hands in a way that effects both meridians and fascia. You can learn how to do this by taking my FascioMeridian™ Release class (feel free to steal that name, it’s not really trademarked, yet, haha).
  2. nerve I highlight theories according to current research that can be applied to any modality. I prioritize creating an environment of trust by honoring an individual’s needs and requests. Manual applications work because favorable signals are registered by nerve endings then processed by the brain. Safe, skilled touch feels really good and this in turn communicates a relaxation response to the whole body. I share my favorite manual approaches to accomplish this and you are free to use them as you like.

So, here is where I leave you. How will you invest your time and money in future education? Wherever it is, may you invest in yourself with eyes wide open 🙂

This is an expansion of this post I made on the Pinpoint Education Forum. Please join us on Facebook if you haven’t already!

Introducing the 1st Blog Post!

April 19, 2016 by Tania Leave a Comment

[Written while listening to this. Comments are welcome below.]

Pinpoint Bodywork Facebook LaunchYessss! I’m very excited to present Pinpoint Bodywork’s very first blog post. It’s been a little under a week since soft-launching the site on Facebook on April 13, 2016. Since then I’ve been sifting through ideas of how to kick off this posting extravaganza. It finally dawned on me a good starting point would be to explore one very important reason why this site was born in the first place.

Here we go

I’ll spare you the nitty-gritty details of my background (if you want to know more, you can go here). Long story short: I’ve been an LMT since 1994. At that time, there was limited information about the actual effects of massage on the body (there were many fair guesses though) and there was ZERO information on what the real world would be like after I was done with school. I was basically thrust into the world clueless and hungry at a time when the internet was just becoming a thing no one ever dreamed you’d be able to watch TV shows on. So, I’ve really had to dig deep for much of what I’ve learned. And I’m still digging.

You’d think having access to lightning fast internet connections would make digging for information easier for everyone, but it doesn’t. It’s become more challenging and the proof of that is in the puddin’. In this case, the puddin’ is the true state of the profession of massage therapy (particularly in the United States). We have TOO MUCH information, and unfortunately much of it is bogus.

Where are we going?

We were doing well for a while with being considered sorta-kinda-maybe healthcare professionals, but then something slowly began changing. Credibility began slipping through the fingers of our progress (some may disagree with this statement, and that is o.k. but like it or not, there are plenty of sentiments to back it up). Up until the 90s, massage was widely covered by insurance companies and now the ability for MTs to earn a living by receiving reimbursement is dwindling and losing ground as we speak. Do you wonder why that is? No no no, big pharma is not to blame. We are the ones who have been holding ourselves back.

Photo credit: AMTA

Before moving on, it is important to know a brief history of modern massage therapy. It puts our place in the world into perspective and it will make you proud. You can read a fantastic summary of it here (article by Patricia J. Benjamin, Ph.D., L.M.T., and AMTA National Historian).

Now, I’m not sure what happened between the birth of modern massage and where we are today, but massage therapy has yet to realize its full capability. This may be a $12.1 billion industry, but we still have a very long way to go in walking side by side with other healthcare professionals. I won’t get into all of the reasons why right now, because this blog post would turn into a 1,000 page report and ain’t nobody got time for that. But for starters, the profession of massage therapy is stuck in the middle of a huge identity crisis. And it can only move forward if everyone does their part in helping to sort out its identity. The big kick in the pants is much of this sorting out process entails permanently discarding outdated beliefs and myths and stepping onto the concrete evidence available to us as of 2016. This is what I like to call “the separation of church and state” in massage therapy. However, accomplishing this has been a lot more challenging than one may imagine. You’ll see what I mean 😉

Where do YOU want US to go?

“Science is a method for deciding whether what we choose to believe has a basis in the laws of nature or not.” -Marcia McNutt, geophysicist

digging-PinpointBodyworkThere is a divide in the profession of those that want to move it forward (even if it means simplifying the definition of the service we provide, which is actually a good thing) and those who are settled in the ways of false claims. There are those who remain ever curious and those who never question what they’ve been told to believe. I used to be one to buy into anything that sounded cool, mystical, or mysterious. But as I began digging (initially looking for evidence to support the claims of the cool special things I thought I knew about), I began discovering there was a lot wrong with what I learned- or if not entirely wrong, what I learned was highly inaccurate. And to make matters worse, there was no evidence to support it, or if there was it had since been refuted. My world of knowledge collapsed and it was the best thing that could have ever happened to the way I approached my work as a MT. The truth will set you free, but may hurt just a little at first 😉

To be fair, some of the stuff I was taught was based on the best information available at the time. But today there is better data and new discoveries are being made as I write this. Now it is time for massage therapy to catch up with itself and realize its true purpose so more people may benefit from it, both within and outside of the profession.

I will end this post with a link to this article titled When Will Massage Therapy Believe In Itself? by Dr. Christopher Moyer.

Dr. Moyer is a behavioral scientist and massage researcher whose work has opened my eyes on many levels. He is also co-author of the textbook Massage Therapy: Integrating Research and Practice. His article sums up perfectly one of the most important reasons behind creating this site: separating the facts from the fluff. It also addresses a truth that is hard for some to swallow. We can believe whatever we like, but as healthcare professionals we cannot present personal beliefs as facts and make medical claims based upon them. Doing so is hurting the credibility of our profession.

Let’s get to work.

Leave a comment below or you are welcome to start a discussion in the Pinpoint Bodywork Facebook Forum!

Later alligators!

 

Alt Text Here

Alt Text Here


Alt Text Here
Our MOST reliable professional publication.


Alt Text Here

Alt Text Here

Alt Text Here

Pediatric massage volunteer program providing hands-on care to orphans and children affected by HIV/AIDS and other disabilities in Nepal and Vietnam. Find out more.

Subscribe to Our Monthly Newsletter!

Blog Roll

  • Employee Misclassification in Massage Therapy: Must read for Independent Contractors
  • Modalites vs. Concepts in Massage Therapy
  • AMTA 2017 School Summit
  • I am a massage therapist, not a “healer”
  • Beware the Hipsterization of Cupping in Massage Therapy

Follow our Facebook groups

Alt Text Here

and the Pinpoint Education Forum

March 14&15 2020 in NYC

Alt Text Here
Get in on this class!

Instagram follow @pinpointeducation

@pinpointedu

***
“If there is one thing I’ve learned in my years on this planet, it’s that the happiest and most fulfilled people I’ve known are those who devoted themselves to something bigger and more profound than merely their own self-interest." -John Glenn 1921-2016


© 2021 PinpointEducation.com. All rights reserved. Since 2017.
Powered by the Rainmaker Platform.

CLASSES • FORUMS • LIBRARY • BLOG • CONTACT

Privacy • Terms • Refunds

We use cookies to personalize your experience on our website and to keep everything secure and running properly. By clicking the consent button, you agree to allow the site to use, collect and/or store cookies.
I accept